Study suggests people willing to take orders from a robot boss (w/ video)

Study suggests people willing to take orders from a robot boss (w/ video)

( —A study conducted by a team of researchers at Human Computer Interaction (MCI) Lab in Manitoba Canada, has revealed evidence that suggests that people can be prodded into doing something they don't want to do, by a robot. They've posted a blog entry on their web site describing an experiment they carried out to learn more about how people might respond to a robot boss, versus a human one, and the results they found.

The experiment consisted of asking volunteers to complete different tasks, some fun (singing songs they liked), some tedious and boring (changing file name extensions for a very large number of files). Some of the volunteers were asked to perform the tasks by a human being, others were asked to do the same tasks by a small friendly-looking Aldebaran Nao humanoid .

The volunteers and their taskmasters were set up in an office-type environment, with desks set apart from one another. The participants were filmed as they carried out the experiment and the researchers analyzed the results afterwards. All of the volunteers were told repeatedly before the experiment that they could stop any task they chose at any time, with no negative consequences.

In studying the video, the researchers found that 46 percent of the volunteers (both male and female) complied with a request to perform a task (which took 80 minutes) they didn't want to do, when asked to do so by the robot, compared to 86 percent compliance when asked by a human "boss." The researchers note the lower percentage but also point out that nearly half of those who participated complied when asked to do something they didn't want to do, when asked by a robot.

The researchers also noted that many of the volunteers argued with the robot, and interacted with it as if it were human. Most apparently believed that the robot was issuing requests autonomously (it wasn't, a human being was behind a glass wall controlling things) and responded accordingly. They also found that some of the volunteers even tried bartering, either with themselves or the robot, by requesting another task or by suggesting out loud that perhaps the robot was malfunctioning.

The research is being carried out to learn more about how future humans might interact with future robots in real workplace environments. The team's initial findings indicate that humans will not summarily dismiss a robot authority figure, and many will do as it asks. The team plans to continue with its research, no doubt, looking to find the limits of such interactions.

Explore further

'Friendly' robots could allow for more realistic human-android relationships

More information: HCI Lab: … -as-a-robot-commands

© 2014

Citation: Study suggests people willing to take orders from a robot boss (w/ video) (2014, March 18) retrieved 16 September 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 18, 2014
Ah, the slippery slope. First the experiment - and then the applied reality. Robo-Cop is just around the corner.

Let's face it we're already taking orders from computers (robots without mobility) and there are a lot of people that take orders lower intelligence beings - not only from their preadolescent children, but their dogs and cats as well.

Mar 19, 2014
ESPECIALLY when they say, "Come vis me if you vant to live."

Mar 19, 2014
A much longer term study is needed. In this study, it's new, unfamiliar. When people become accustomed to the robot, in whatever form, with whatever capabilities, they will deal with it in whatever way makes things most expeditious for them. People will come to know how autonomous it is, how much authority it has, any quirks that can be exploited, etc.

Mar 19, 2014
Taking orders from a robot is my preferred way because a person brings too much psychological "baggage" with the work order.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more