Can 3-D-printing musical instruments produce better sound than traditional instruments?

sound wave
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Music is an art, but it is also a science involving vibrating reeds and strings, sound waves and resonances. The study of acoustics can help scientists produce beautiful music even with musical instruments fashioned with high-tech methods, such as 3-D printing.

Xiaoyu Niu, from the University of Chinese Academy Sciences, and other researchers studied the quality of a 3-D-printed ukulele and compared it to a standard wooden instrument. Niu will present the group's results in a talk, "A Comparison on Sound Quality of PLA 3-D Printing Ukulele and Single Board Wooden Ukulele," at the 178th Meeting of the Acoustical Society of America, which will be held Dec. 2-6, at the Hotel del Coronado in San Diego. Niu's talk is part of a session on "General Topics in Musical Acoustics," to be held beginning at 9:00 a.m. on Thursday, Dec. 5.

The ukulele studied by Niu's group was created with a 3-D printer using a type of plastic known as polylactic acid, or PLA. This substance has become quite popular for producing 3-D-printed objects, since the printing can be done at low temperatures.

Niu found under the same plucking force, the wooden ukulele was louder than the 3-D-printed one. The investigators also found the timbre of the two instruments was different. The wooden instrument exhibited more high-frequency vibrations than the 3-D-printed ukulele.

Can 3D-printing musical instruments produce better sound than traditional instruments?
Comparison of a 3D-printed ukulele (left) and a standard wooden instrument (right) Credit: Xiaoyu Niu

"We found that the A-weighted sound pressure of the 3-D-printed instrument was less than that of the wooden one," Niu said. A-weighting is used to account for the relative loudness of low frequency sounds perceived by the human ear.

To explain these differences, the investigators carried out computer calculations using a software package known as COMSOL. They first modeled the ukulele shape mathematically. Using formulas for sound resonance and acoustics, they were able to explain the differences between a standard wooden ukulele and the new high-tech 3-D-printed version. Niu and co-workers plan to continue their work to further improve this mathematical model.


Explore further

First rifle constructed from printed 3D parts by gun enthusiast in Canada (w/ Video)

Citation: Can 3-D-printing musical instruments produce better sound than traditional instruments? (2019, December 5) retrieved 5 July 2020 from https://techxplore.com/news/2019-12-d-printing-musical-instruments-traditional.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
6 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments