EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do

EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do
In this Thursday, March 26, 2020, file photo, Ashley Bullard, left, sits on the porch of her family's rural home in North Sandwich, N.H., as her daughters Raven, center, a senior in high school, and Willow, right, a freshman at Brandeis University, try to complete their classwork from home during the virus outbreak on a very limited internet connection. In the town of 1,200 best known as the setting for the movie "On Golden Pond," broadband is scarce. The Senate's $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure plan includes a $65 billion investment in broadband that the White House says will "deliver reliable, affordable, high-speed internet to every household." Credit: AP Photo/Charles Krupa, File

The Senate's $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure plan includes a $65 billion investment in broadband that the White House says will "deliver reliable, affordable, high-speed internet to every household."

It may not actually achieve that, but it's a major step in that direction. The broadband funding is a "great down payment" on the Biden administration's far-reaching goals of connecting all Americans and making internet more affordable, said Matt Wood, a broadband policy expert at the consumer advocacy group Free Press. Critically important is $14 billion aimed at helping low-income Americans pay for service.

The ""—the persistent U.S. gap between the broadband haves and have-nots—became glaringly obvious during the pandemic as school, work and health care shifted online. Tens of millions either don't have or, if they do have access to a local phone or , can't afford to pay for it.

More radical industry changes laid out in the Biden administration's original $100 billion plan, like promoting alternatives to the dominant phone and cable industries and hinting at price regulation, didn't survive bipartisan negotiations over a bill that had to attract Republican support. Among the bill's big winners, in fact, are those same internet service providers.

EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do
In this Wednesday, Aug. 4, 2021, file photo, Skylar Core, right, a worker with the Mason County (Wash.) Public Utility District, installs a hanger onto fiber optic cable as it comes off of a spool, while working with a team to install broadband internet service to homes in a rural area surrounding Lake Christine near Belfair, Wash. Credit: AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File

The Senate passed the $1 trillion infrastructure bill Tuesday, 69-30, with support from both Democrats and Republicans. The House is expected to consider it in September.

THE DIGITAL DIVIDE

The Federal Communications Commission says about 14 million Americans don't have access to broadband at the speeds necessary to work and study online—25 megabits per second downloads and 3 mbps uploads—but acknowledges that its maps are faulty. Outside groups have made higher estimates.

Phone and cable companies don't have incentives to build internet infrastructure in , where customers are sparser and they may not make their money back. That's traditionally where government subsidies to the industry have come into play: About $47 billion to rural internet from 2009 through 2017, and an additional $20 billion for rural broadband over the next decade and another $9 billion for high-speed wireless internet called 5G in sparsely populated regions.

EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do
In this Friday June 5, 2020, file photo, fourth-grader Sammiayah Thompson, left, and her brother, third-grader Nehemiah Thompson, work outside in their yard on laptops provided by their school system for distant learning in Hartford, Conn. The Senate's $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure plan includes a $65 billion investment in broadband that the White House says will "deliver reliable, affordable, high-speed internet to every household." It may not actually achieve that, but it's a major step. Credit: AP Photo/Jessica Hill, File

But there are also tens of millions of people today who have access to the internet and just don't sign up, most often because they can't afford it, in both cities and remote areas. The National Urban League estimates that number at 30 million households.

FOCUSING ON AFFORDABILITY

The Senate bill would provide about $14 billion toward a $30 monthly benefit that helps low-income people pay for internet, extending a pandemic-era emergency program.

"What makes this historic is the focus on affordability," said Jenna Leventoff of Public Knowledge, which advocates for more funding for broadband. The bill, should it become law, is "going to help a lot of people that were otherwise unable to connect."

An existing program, known as Lifeline, aimed to help solve this affordability issue before. But it only provides $9.25 a month, which doesn't go far for internet plans. It has also been a target of Republicans, who say it has fraud and abuse problems.

EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do
In this Wednesday, Aug. 4, 2021, file photo, workers with the Mason County (Wash.) Public Utility District install fiber optic cable, as part of a project to bring broadband internet service to homes in a rural area surrounding Lake Christine near Belfair, Wash. Credit: AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File

Industry groups have also advocated for a permanent broadband benefit. Broadband companies, if they choose to participate, will gain additional customers. The program is "a plus for all ISPs," said Evercore ISI analyst Vijay Jayant.

The legislation directs the FCC to create rules intended to protect consumers from companies that could push them to sign up for more expensive services in connection with the benefit and against other "unjust and unreasonable" practices.

MONEY FOR NETWORKS

The bill provides about $42 billion in grants to states, who in turn will funnel it to ISPs to expand networks where people don't have good internet service. Companies that take this money will have to offer a low-cost service option. Government regulators will approve the price of that service.

The bill requires that internet projects come with minimum speeds of 100 mbps down/20 up, a big step up from current requirements. But some advocates are concerned that it's still too slow, and argue that the federal government may have to spend big again down the line to rebuild networks that aren't up to par for future needs.

EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do
In this Wednesday, Aug. 4, 2021, file photo, Carl Roath, left, a worker with the Mason County (Wash.) Public Utility District, pulls fiber optic cable off of a spool, as he works with a team to install broadband internet service to homes in a rural area surrounding Lake Christine near Belfair, Wash. Credit: AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File

Cable companies are also happy that the funding is primarily dedicated to areas that don't currently have service. Some advocates had hoped the government would step in and fund competition to cable so that people had more choices. Others saw that as wasteful.

The Biden administration's initial plan promised to promote local government networks, cooperatives and nonprofits as alternatives to for-profit phone and cable companies. Under the Senate's plan now, such groups aren't prioritized, but they can still get money from states for networks. The telecom industry has lobbied against municipal networks; about 20 states restrict them.

Senate negotiators also left loopholes in language around an attempt to end what's known as "digital redlining"—when telecom companies provide upgraded internet service in wealthier parts of town but leave others without good service. The bill says the FCC must create rules to stop this practice, "insofar as technically and economically feasible." But the whole reason telecoms leave some areas with subpar service is because those neighborhoods are not as profitable, said Leventoff.

How strong these requirements are will depend on what the FCC does. The agency, however, is hamstrung. The White House has not nominated a permanent chair and the FCC is missing a third Democratic commissioner that would allow it to take on controversial items.

EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do
In this Wednesday, Aug. 4, 2021, file photo, Travis Sheetz, a worker with the Mason County (Wash.) Public Utility District, installs fiber optic cable on a utility pole, while working with a team to bring broadband internet service to homes in a rural area surrounding Lake Christine near Belfair, Wash. Credit: AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File

Still, industry groups and proponents of expanding access both say the legislation should help get more people online.

"This bill will not increase choice and lower prices for everyone. But that's not the right measure," Wood said. "It will make real, far more affordable for millions of people who today cannot afford it, and it will make faster networks available to millions more. That's a big deal."


Explore further

Emergency program to give people $50 off internet bill

© 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

Citation: EXPLAINER: What the $65B broadband service plan will do (2021, August 11) retrieved 24 October 2021 from https://techxplore.com/news/2021-08-65b-broadband.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
3 shares

Feedback to editors