Flushing toilets aren't the solution to South Africa's sanitation problem

Flushing toilets aren't the solution to South Africa's sanitation problem
HTClean Hydrothermal carbonisation unit: Class 1 non-sewered sanitation system (for a single household) developed by Helbling and funded through the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation’s Reinvented Toilet Challenge. Credit: ANSI

Many households in some of South Africa's biggest cities have been facing water restrictions in recent times—sometimes lasting for days at a time. People have had to make tough choices. For example, if you have a bottle of water in your house, are you going to drink it or use it for flushing the toilet?

Sanitation scientist Dr. Preyan Arumugam-Nanoolal argues that, even without , it simply doesn't make sense to keep flushing drinkable down the toilet. She and her colleagues have been evaluating alternative sanitation technologies. Ina Skosana had a conversation with her about this research and innovations surrounding it.

Describe South Africa's sanitation landscape

Around 65% of South Africa's population have access to waterborne sanitation such as flushing toilets connected to a sewer network, septic tank or conservancy tank. Another 19% have ventilated improved , while 13% have pit toilets with no ventilation pipes. The remaining population either have pour flush toilets, chemical toilets or composting toilets, or they use buckets. Unfortunately, about 1% of the population still practice open defecation because they have no access to any sort of toilet facility.

South Africa is a water scarce country that has faced extreme weather events in recent years. For example in 2018 Cape Town faced severe drought and the possibility of running out of water. More recently, the east coast city of Durban was hit by floods which damaged bulk water and sanitation infrastructure. With the country's challenges around water management and availability, it's just not feasible and viable to continue with waterborne sanitation.

Conventional flushing toilets use around nine to 12 liters of water per flush. And that is potable water.

Moreover, according to South Africa's latest Green Drop report, the performance of current conventional wastewater treatment works is alarming. Only 23 out of the 995 wastewater treatment works evaluated achieved Green Drop status by scoring above 90%.

It seems practical for us to transition towards the adoption of non-sewered sanitation technologies.

What are non-sewered sanitation systems?

Non-sewered sanitation technologies collect, convey and fully treat the acceptable input onsite.

Instead of your waste going from your toilet via a sewer to a treatment works offsite, this technology treats your waste onsite and allows the treated outputs to be safely reused or disposed of.

Flushing toilets aren't the solution to South Africa's sanitation problem
HTClean (sideview)

These technologies can be installed in the household and larger systems can be implemented for schools or communities. They consist of a front end, which is your facility, and a back end, which is the treatment facility.

Pictured here is one of the reinvented toilets funded by the Gates Foundation. The HTClean, developed for a single household, uses a vacuum flush evacuation mechanism thus. This reduces the water required to 0.2-0.9 liters per flush. The urine and fecal matter are mechanically separated at the back end and treated by high temperature and high pressure processing. The treated liquid output is reused for flushing.

What are the benefits of this toilet technology?

Non-sewered sanitation is less dependent on water. It uses conventional flush (less than 6 liters), pour flush, dry toilets or novel evacuation mechanisms that use mechanical forces with little to no water. And its treated output can be reused.

Non-sewered sanitation fully treats feces and urine. The treated solid output can be used as fertilizer while the treated liquid output can be used for flushing or crop irrigation. Our fecal and urine matter is a valuable resource.

How close is this to being a reality in South Africa?

I am involved in the training and awareness around a global standard called ISO 30500, which has been adopted in South Africa as SANS 30500. This standard provides guidance for the design, performance and safety requirements of non-sewered sanitation systems. It also considers the sustainability of these systems over a functional life-span.

We at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, on behalf of the Water Research Commission, are coordinating the development of a certification scheme which will allow these technologies to be certified against the standard and enter the market.

Two technologies which were developed through the Reinvented Toilet Challenge funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation have been licensed by two South African companies to be manufactured in South Africa. These technologies are being tested in the field through the South African Sanitation Technology Enterprise Program. The program provides a platform for sanitation innovators and commercial partners to take their technologies from the prototype development phase to commercialisation.

The Department of Water and Sanitation has already identified the benefits of non-sewered sanitation and recently launched the Sanitation Technology Technical Coordinating Committee. The committee's function is to help develop a process to assess and validate appropriate sanitation technologies, get them certified and accredited, and guide their adoption and commercialization. However, while the regulator can make recommendations, it's really the municipalities that make the decisions.

I believe that through certification will provide users and water service authorities and municipalities with peace of mind that these technologies are safe and reliable. While the cost of developing, testing and certifying non-sewered technologies may appear high now, it all boils down to the economics of scale. Over time, a higher demand will make these systems cheaper to manufacture and affordable for households.

Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation: Flushing toilets aren't the solution to South Africa's sanitation problem (2022, November 18) retrieved 9 February 2023 from https://techxplore.com/news/2022-11-flushing-toilets-solution-south-africa.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Video: Why flush toilets are wasteful

17 shares

Feedback to editors