Good news in an era of fake news—the public is becoming wiser about how the media works

Good news in an era of fake news—the public is becoming wiser about how the media works
‘Believe me’ is one of Donald Trump’s most often-used catchphrases. Credit: Evan El-Amin/Shutterstock

Storytelling is a key part of human culture. Where politics and power are concerned, stories become something not only to be told, but to be shaped and influenced – so that, in many cases, they are used to mislead or deceive. Recent research for a lecture on "fake news" led me to wonder if there was a reason why it seems to spike at certain times. I came to the conclusion that three main factors seem to create the conditions for fake news to surge: a step change in communication or communication technology coupled with political uncertainty and armed conflict.

There's no doubt that the world is still learning to adapt to the impact of social media. Twitter was a fledgling platform ten years ago, now it's the way the president of the United States talks to the world. It allows him to feel in control of his message. Political power has always wanted to do that: from the battles of the ancient world right the way through human history. In Britain, one might think of the Tudor dynasty's attempts to control what was at the time new media – the printing press – to consolidate their initially tenuous hold on the English throne in the late 15th century.

This was a time of both political uncertainty and – and the printing press played its major role in creating that conflict and instability.

Snow job

With the benefit of hindsight, Napoleon Bonaparte's campaign in Russia is remembered as a military disaster – but it didn't look like that to begin with, as the Grande Armée advanced on Moscow. The Russian commander, Marshal Kutuzov – facing questions over his tactics – made sure that when the tide started to turn his way, he made the most of it. Battle trophies were shown off to the soldiers. "Whatever his limitations as a tactician, Kutuzov was a master when it came to public relations, and his troops' morale," wrote Dominic Lieven in Russia against Napoleon.

Few in the rank and file of Kutuzov's army would have been able to read or write. The only accounts of the action would have been from official dispatches, or officers' diaries and letters. The message was fairly easily controlled.

Russia's war against France, Britain and Turkey, later in the 19th century was a different matter. The Crimea of the 1850s is remembered in journalism history for the debut of the "miserable parent of the luckless tribe", as William Howard Russell – usually considered the first war correspondent – described himself.

His pioneering reporting had influence long beyond his era. The British government was not just worried about the enemy when World War I broke out. They were worried about the press. Soaring newspaper circulations and literacy rates which had greatly increased as the result of widening education – not to mention the huge ambitions of the press barons of the age – meant that the newspapers were credited with unprecedented influence. Strict legislation was passed to ensure they did not use it in a way likely to contradict the government. Some did try to report freely, but were stopped. At least one, Philip Gibbs, who later toed the government line, was threatened with being shot.

Those who were allowed to report sent uplifting accounts that soldiers did not recognise. There were infamous atrocity stories, too – one of the most shocking being that the Germans were boiling down human corpses for soap. It was fake news of the worst kind.

Broadcast power

The next time Europe went to war and dragged in large parts of the rest of the world, radio dominated. Never before had the human voice had the ability to be a simultaneous, mass medium. Its novelty spawned new propaganda opportunities. Among the most infamous exponents was William Joyce, known as "Lord Haw-Haw" who broadcast Nazi propaganda in English. The nickname was an attempt to undermine him. He was taken seriously enough, though, to be hanged as a traitor after the war.

The Cold War – a time of massive political tension, and proxy wars – produced fake news that grabbed global attention. Among them: the KGB-inspired canard, Operation INFEKTION, which tried to convince people that the AIDS virus was a product of US biological warfare experiments. There was an uncanny contemporary echo of this when RT seemed to give credence to stories that the US department of defense might be to blame for Ebola.

The big lie

So "fake news" is not new. What arguably is new is its scale, and participatory nature. Today, anyone with access to social media can join in. Political instability and war – such as the world is plagued with today – create the incentive for governments and individuals to do so, and new technology and uses of that technology have made it easier to spread.

If there is good news in the age of fake news, it is this: previous eras have come to and end. Politicians and publics have become familiar with the way new media work and have done so in the eras of journalism from printing to mass circulation newspapers to broadcasting and now . Journalism regained trust and credibility after World War 1. It can again.


Explore further

'Fake news' didn't change US election outcome: study

Provided by The Conversation

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation: Good news in an era of fake news—the public is becoming wiser about how the media works (2017, March 6) retrieved 23 September 2019 from https://techxplore.com/news/2017-03-good-news-era-fake-newsthe.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
22 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 08, 2017
Of course we're getting wiser - this is why we elected trump despite the unprecedented media onslaught against him. And also why he will be able to do what he promised to do despite their continued efforts to stop him by any and all means.

Its why so many leftists have lost elections at every level across the country.

Its why most every office holder who promotes restrictive gun laws gets voted out of office.

And its why every time a colbert or a maher or a whoopie goldberg or an alec baldwin get a laugh, more voters flee that sinking ship.

The medias time is past. The public now knows where to go to to get the truth and its not the 6 o'clock news. It never was.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more