February 11, 2021
New 3-D-printed antenna designs reduce cost, weight and size
U.S. Naval Research Laboratory experts created and tested 3-D-printed antennas and arrays to advance radar technology and enable new applications for the U.S. Navy.
The lightweight and rapid production of 3-D-printed parts make it an attractive alternative to traditional manufacturing that often requires expensive materials and specialized equipment.
"3-D printing is a way to produce rapid prototypes and get through multiple design iterations very quickly, with minimal cost," said NRL electrical engineer Anna Stumme. "The light weight of the printed parts also allows us to take technology to new applications, where the heavy weight of solid metal parts used to restrict us."
Radar systems perform critical functions for the Navy, and remain an important part of maritime navigation and national defense. Parts for antennas and arrays, which are multiple connected antennas working together as one, may unexpectedly break or wear out requiring replacement. Traditionally, parts are ordered or intricately machined out of metal, sometimes taking weeks to produce. 3-D-printed radar parts, such as a cylindrical array, which provide 360-degree visibility, can be produced within hours versus several days using traditional methods due to the reduced machining and assembly time.
In addition to the production benefits, the relatively low cost of 3-D printing materials enable researchers to test multiple versions of parts at minimal overhead. The perfected prototypes can then be machined using traditional methods. Once a prototype is successfully produced, whether 3-D printed or traditionally manufactured, it must undergo rigorous testing before it is used operationally. That's the "super power" said Stumme and her colleagues—they can quickly perform a variety of tests on new designs using 3-D-printed parts.
"We are not trying to say we need to 3-D print everything and put it on a ship because that is not realistic," Stumme said. "We don't necessarily know how it would hold up in that environment. For us, it's a way to test more design iterations in a short amount of time."
In early 2019, Stumme submitted a paper comparing 3-D printed parts against traditionally manufactured parts at the Antenna Applications Symposium. She won the student paper contest for her research.
Stumme and her colleagues are investigating how weight-and-size- constrained applications, such as unmanned aerial vehicles or small ships, can benefit from 3-D-printed parts. Many of the 3-D prototypes are printed using light weight nylon in NRL's Laboratory for Autonomous Systems Research facility. Once the part is printed, it undergoes a process called electroplating.
During the electroplating process, a thin coat of metal is applied to the printed part. Electroplating provides a conductive surface for the device to radiate as intended; something that isn't feasible with plastic alone. The result is a lightweight prototype that can then be evaluated for a variety of attributes, such as surface roughness—a major factor in the functionality for antenna elements.
Stumme collaborates with NRL materials scientists from the across NRL, who perform critical surface roughness characterization. Surface roughness characterization provides an assessment of the coating on an antenna, and the impact roughness has on its performance.
"Surface roughness is important for wave guides and antennas because it can cause scattering losses and result in a less efficient antenna," said Nick Charipar, head of the Applied Materials and Systems Section. "Antennas radiate and receive waves. So if a wave runs along a rough surface it is distorted and the energy may not go where you want it to go."
Charipar and his team, part of NRL's Material Science & Technology Division, prototype 3-D printed parts for the NRL's Radar Division. Once the part is created, researchers investigate how the material features impact functionality of the radar. Each 3-D printer has unique characteristics that may alter product performance. If researchers can figure out the optimal parameters for specific 3-D printed parts, Stumme and her colleagues agree ships could become self-reliant for those critical parts anywhere in the world.
Despite current COVID-19 restrictions, research at NRL continues to thrive from a distance. Later this year, Stumme and her colleagues plan to demonstrate new prototype cylindrical array apertures for an X-band surveillance radar demonstration in a laboratory setting. The X-band surveillance radar is designed to search the area surrounding a particular platform, such as a ship. They are exploring integrating cylindrical arrays into the masts of smaller vessels using microwave photonics and optical fibers.
"Cylindrical arrays are advantageous because they provide full 360-degree visibility," said Mark Dorsey, head of the Antenna Section in the Radar Analysis Branch of the Radar Division and project principal investigator. "Optical fibers are valuable because they can allow for long separations between the antenna itself and where the processing is conducted."
Using optical fibers reduces the number of components required on a Navy ship's mast, further reducing heat and weight constraints. The demonstration will include testing traditionally manufactured and 3-D printed versions of the array to compare performance. Stumme designed both versions.
In 2021, the team is scheduled to perform field testing on the prototype. The demonstration will be in the final year of their four-year effort to make the array more practical to use on smaller platforms, and show how to use arrays easily with optical fibers. Funding for the research is provided by NRL base funding.