May 12, 2021
Court orders Air France, Airbus trial over Rio-Paris crash
Air France and Airbus must stand trial on involuntary manslaughter charges over the 2009 crash of a Rio de Janeiro to Paris flight that killed all 228 people on board, a Paris court ruled on Wednesday.
Flight AF447 plunged into the Atlantic Ocean during a storm on June 1, 2009, the deadliest crash in Air France's history.
The court followed the general prosecutor's recommendation, overturning an earlier decision to drop the case against both the French flagship carrier and Europe's top aircraft maker.
It took two years to find the wreckage of the Airbus A330 jet, which was eventually located by remote-controlled submarines at a depth of 3,900 metres (13,000 feet).
Investigators determined the crash was caused by errors by pilots disorientated by faulty speed monitoring equipment.
The general prosecutor's call for a manslaughter trial against both companies went beyond the Paris prosecutor's initial demand that only Air France should face manslaughter charges.
Both prosecuting teams contested a 2019 decision to drop the charges by the two investigating magistrates assigned to the case, who said they could not ascribe fault to the companies in what appeared to be a case of pilot error.
'Underestimated the gravity'
But prosecutors accused Air France of indirectly causing the tragedy by providing insufficient training on how to react in case of malfunction of the so-called Pitot tubes, which enable pilots to monitor their speed.
A source close to the case said the appeals court found Air France failed to programme specific training and information sessions for crew "that would have been necessary".
That failure "prevented pilots from responding in the correct way", the source said.
This contradicted earlier findings that the combination of elements leading to the disaster would have been very difficult to foresee.
Faults in monitoring equipment had already been detected in the months leading up to the crash, and the court found that Airbus "underestimated the gravity" of the risks "and did not take the necessary steps to urgently inform crews", the source said.
The pilots reacted incorrectly when the plane stalled after the speed sensors froze over as it flew through a large cloud at high altitude.
Lawyers for Airbus said they would lodge an appeal against a decision that "in no way reflects the conclusions of the investigation, which resulted in no charges against Airbus in this case".
Air France told AFP it had committed "no criminal act" and that it, too, reserved the right to lodge an appeal.
The Paris appeals court decision had been much awaited by victims' families.
"It's a huge satisfaction to feel that we have finally been heard by the courts," Daniele Lamy, president of an association of victims' families, said after Wednesday's ruling.
"But we still deplore that it took 12 long years to get to this point. Twelve years of unwavering determination, full of uncertainty, of tricky and obscure procedures and of dejection, but never resignation," she said.
"I have to admit that we stopped believing in this outcome these past few years," said Ophelie Toulliou, whose brother died in the crash. "It's a great relief for us."
In Brazil, the head of an association of parents of victims said the decision had been a long time coming.
"But we have received the news with mixed feelings because Air France and Airbus can still appeal," said Faria Marinho, who lost a child in the crash.
"The victims will not come back, but it would be satisfying if someone was punished," the 77-year-old added.
The French pilots' association welcomed the decision, with a spokesman saying "accusations were aimed at the pilots, while the aircraft maker and airline were cleared of all wrongdoing".
But the truth, he said, was that "the instruments didn't function the way they should have".
Since the disaster, pilot training on dealing with unforeseen circumstances has been stepped up in France and several other countries.
Air France and Airbus have stood trial in France once before, over a crash that killed 87 people onboard an A320 near the eastern city of Strasbourg in January 1992. Both were found not guilty.
© 2021 AFP